Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

25 reviews

+1 (423) 491-8163

Website

Photos

Starting on the far left and going clockwise- Chocolate cream, Peanut butter, I-40, Chewy chocolate chip

First time we have visited this pie store.

Pie from Buttermilk Sky and drinks from fizz soda bar. Perfect pairing!

3135 Peoples St Ste 300

Johnson City, TN 37604

+1 (423) 491-8163

http://www.buttermilkskypie.com

History

Opened in 2017 and two year recipient of the Johnson City Choice award for Bakeries.

Specialties

Our business specializes in baking delicious pies. Whether you want to eat in, pick up, or order delivery you will have delicious pies all year round!

Also at this address

Bentley Medical

Natural Pet Supply

5 reviews

Menchie's

15 reviews

Klacie's Candles & Boutique

Find related places

Candy Store

Bakery

Dessert

Places To Eat

Ice Cream

Reviews

4.025 reviews

Janine B.

1/26/2019

The I-40 is all you need to know. Period! Lol Seriously it was delicious. I liked the apple as well, the crust on these pies are the best crusts ever. I've tried the apple, but not fond of the...

Read more on Yelp

Joseph H.

11/29/2024

Key lime doesn't taste like key lime. Very overpriced. Apple custard was nothing special. We were very disappointed in both.

Read more on Yelp

Joey K.

11/24/2024

All I gotta say is yes the pies are great BUT I used to pay maybe $18 max for a pie and to now see the pies are $32 for a 9" is ridiculous.

Read more on Yelp

K. N.

12/12/2023

We love homemade pies and couldn't wait to try BSPS. Went in for a pumpkin and they were sold out, so we got a cherry and went home. You can certainly tell the quality of the ingredients and real...

Read more on Yelp

Savannah A.

1/30/2022

The reviews are right: These pies are FANTASTIC. My party enjoyed 4 inch versions of the key lime, I-40, chocolate chip, buttermilk, apple, and pecan. Everyone seemed thrilled with their...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?

Eating places, Fast food restaurants and stands

Insomnia Cookies

•

"This spot is just expensive for no reason. I wanted to try it and was recommended the chocolate chunk.. the cookie was $3, barely warm and was the most basic chocolate chip cookie. I could've gone..."