What's for Dessert? makes pastries and desserts, including wedding cakes, speciality cakes (think sponge cakes, bishop's cakes, marble and swirl cakes) and cookies in flavors like chocolate chip, butter and oatmeal raisin. The bakery also takes special orders for cakes and tortes; popular flavors include mousee bombe, strawberry shortcake, cookies 'n cream and dizzy blonde.
The bakery also offers a weekly dinner entree. Previous dinner entrees include turkey tetrazzini and broccoli salad, chicken croquettes, and sausage and peppers.