The Milk Pail is a roadside country store on the westbound side of Montauk Highway Between Water Mill and Bridgehampton. Run by the Halsey family since 1969, the market offers fresh, natural, homegrown, hand-picked and homemade specialty items. Its large selection includes 26 varieties of apples, peaches, pears, cider, jams, syrups, pies and more. Gift packages and daily shipping within the U.S. are also available. Visit the website for recipe ideas.