Island Thrift

$$$$

37 reviews

+1 (631) 923-1753

Website

Photos

$2.99 for used teenage books? CRIME ! (Thrift book prices as always - should be $1.00 for hardcover , .50 cents for paperbacks)

$12.99 for a Target (Covington) hoodie?! CRIME !! Where's my electric chair?

$3.99 for a thin "motel stolen" used white towel !! CRIME !

1770 New York Ave

Huntington Station, NY 11746

+1 (631) 923-1753

http://www.islandthriftstore.com

Island Thrift Store is a local establishment in Huntington Station, NY that offers a variety of second-hand items for sale.

With a focus on sustainability and affordability, this thrift store provides a unique shopping experience for those looking for pre-loved treasures.

Generated from their business information

Also at this address

Model Lounge Limited

Find related places

Shopping

Discount Stores

Second Hand Stores

Reviews

2.537 reviews

Sean B.

11/1/2019

Okay, so there's a lot of negative reviews about how this place is a dump and the prices are a rip off, and of course they're all completely accurate. However, at the end of the day this is still...

Read more on Yelp

Eva E.

10/27/2024

I came to Island Thrift was all intentions to give them the benefit of the doubt, after reading all the negative reviews. As I walk out of this cluster-f*ck of a store, I regret walking in....

Read more on Yelp

Sean S.

10/28/2024

Awful pricing , brainless employees and tons of homeless right outside. I went to purchase 3 books part of a trilogy, 2 were marked as 4.99 which is awful price for this thrift store, one was...

Read more on Yelp

Kona K.

8/25/2023

The place used to be "hit and miss" and now it's "Miss and Miss" . Lots of resellers shop here-- but there is NOTHING to buy ! Then there are the BOOK SCANNING IDIOTS that make a dollar or 2 on...

Read more on Yelp

stevo k.

3/25/2024

I didn't know heaven was real until I went to this place. Deals on top of deals ! Huuuuge selection of products. Customer service is wonderful. I recommend this place and also there other locations!

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?

Sporting camps

North Shore Holiday House

"They are closed during June through mid September, so hurry if you want to visit and shop now! Holiday House offers great clothing, nice housewares and some furniture for very reasonable..."