The First Baptist Church of Cutchogue is located on the corner of Route 48 and Church Lane in Cutchogue. The pastor is Cornelius Fulford. The First Baptist's programs are "centered on individuals' spiritual and community needs. As a church we try to address present day issues which affect our local, national and international communities. As a faith community, First Baptist endeavors to lift up hope and Christian principles as they relate to our members and the community at large."