Commander Cody's Seafood

77 reviews

+1 (631) 749-1851

Photos

41 Smith St

Shelter Island, NY 11964

+1 (631) 749-1851

Commander Cody's Seafood is a quaint restaurant nestled in Shelter Island, NY, known for its fresh seafood offerings and casual dining atmosphere.

With a focus on locally sourced ingredients and a menu featuring classic seafood dishes, Commander Cody's Seafood provides a relaxed dining experience for both locals and visitors alike.

Generated from their business information

Find related places

Food

Farmers Market

Places To Eat

Seafood

Reviews

3.577 reviews

Rodney M.

10/3/2024

Yah babee... a groovvy place to go... nothing fancy, this is a "fish place"... no corn dogs for the kids, paper plates, good food and nice service... as a sidebar, excellent prices and probably...

Read more on Yelp

K L.

9/8/2024

Came here for lunch on a weekday and it was pretty quiet. A no-frills ambiance which was totally fine; food was good and they of course used high-quality seafood. You order at the counter,...

Read more on Yelp

Tanya J.

8/24/2024

Food was decent. Fish was seasoned and fried well done as per my request. Lobster roll was the perfect size not too much and not so little. Service was amazing and this place is black owned so it...

Read more on Yelp

Vicky R.

8/11/2024

We came for a late dinner and we are so happy we did! We got the cocktail shrimp and mussels with fries. The shrimp were so large and juicy. The cocktail sauce had an odd congealed texture so we...

Read more on Yelp

Andy H.

5/8/2024

Solid local option for fresh seafood (mussels, clams, scallops, fish). People rave about their fried chicken and cole slaw. Counter service was helpful and friendly. Has an old world feeling ......

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?