The smell of chocolate and the sights of hundreds of candy varieties are what your senses take in when you enter Criterion Chocolates in Eatontown. For over 80 years, Criterion has been making its treats for customers out of this location. Whether it's chocolate truffles, chocolate-covered pretzels, taffy, candy apples or fudge, you'll find it at Criterion Chocolates. The store offers hundreds of candy varieties that are handmade fresh daily at its factory next door to the store.