Carmen's Restaurant, 50 Joyce Kilmer Ave, New Brunswick, NJ 08901, US

Los Toritos Pizzeria is very popular for its brick-oven, thin-crust pizza and pre-ordered doughs—no sides, no appetizers, and BYOB. Its trademarks are its pepperoni pie, sweet pepper pie, pasta pie, stuffed pizza, Mexican pie and BBQ chicken pie. Don't expect to see an official sign outside Los Toritos anytime soon—everyone knows where it is. Los Toritos opens late in the day and closes fairly early, so make reservations at the beginning of the week and know how many pies your party will want.