Brewster's Italian Cafe

476 reviews

+1 (269) 946-9300

Website

Photos

Shockingly great bread. (You have to ask for it. They don't just bring it)

Kids' menu - scrambled eggs with biscuit

11 W Merchant St

New Buffalo, MI 49117

+1 (269) 946-9300

http://brewstersitaliancafe.com

A locally owned restaurant located in downtown New Buffalo, Michigan; Brewster’s New Buffalo puts a contemporary spin on traditional Italian fare, along with creative, globally inspired dishes. While we're rooted in Italian cuisine, our palette expands far beyond the borders of Italy.

Find related places

Bakery

Places To Eat

Pizza

Restaurants

Reviews

4.0476 reviews

Bailey M.

9/1/2024

Nice atmosphere, friendly service. Our waiter split our bill between our party which was appreciated. Make sure to make a reservation on open table as this is a busy area. We had dinner at 9pm...

Read more on Yelp

Michelle M.

8/26/2024

So very nice. My family took a quick day trip to New Buffalo. They have these cute little shops in this touristy town. And we decided to break bread here. The service is so sweet. It's clean...

Read more on Yelp

Kyla A.

2/9/2025

Amanda was a fantastic server. The cocktails were exactly what we were looking for. The presentation of the food was more than we were anticipating and tasted great! Hats off to the chef...

Read more on Yelp

Maralyn O.

10/19/2024

The service was great, the food was delicious and didn't break my bank account, but I hate when they nail you for a "convenience fee".... I would rather leave that for the server. Also, a woman...

Read more on Yelp

Jessica S.

2/9/2024

I stopped in for some dessert. The texture of the pot de creme was good but the flavor was not quite for me. The tiramisu tasted good at first bite, but the middle and bottom are watery,...

Read more on Yelp

Owner verified

See a problem?