This very popular hole-in-the-wall off Edwards Lane supplies pizza, buffalo wings, wine, beer, salad, cigarettes and Midwestern pop brand Faygo to students and late-nighters all over Hayward and Castro Valley. You can order online and customize your pie by choosing from the four sauces (red, white, garlic and pesto) and 24 toppings including cilantro, garlic and zucchini. Slices range from $2.50 to $4. Most people opt for free delivery, but some choose to dine in.